This is a read only archive of See the shutdown announcement for details.

s20bar_2016_session5  Home:

Session 5

Title: Peer Review
Moderator:  Johannes Breuer
    * Andreas Leimbach
    open peer review: e.g.,
    incentives: list journals you review for on your CV
print culture vs. digital age & "Science 2.0": access, dissemination, archiving...
open access & science/scientists should be in control of the publication process
reviewers & editors as gatekeepers? quality control?
Some Journals have a list of reviewers of the year (speed, amount of reviews, substantial feedback)
evaluation criteria for review(er)s?
reviewing reviews: feedback cycle