This is a read only archive of pad.okfn.org. See the
shutdown announcement
for details.
Open_Education_Working_Group_Call
7th Open Education Working Group Call: Open education meta community online session
Working Group website: http://education.okfn.org
Working Group mailing list: https://lists.okfn.org/mailman/listinfo/open-education
Date: Thursday 4th June at 1pm BST / 2pm CEST - more details to follow on the mailing list.
Where:
Google hangout - (to participate): https://plus.google.com/hangouts/_/hoaevent/AP36tYe9cOSfyAKgwSHTvHuPI8CNbYNigByaY5U66wwK-1LIAOoHDA?authuser=0&hl=en-GB
Google Hangout on Air - (to view): https://plus.google.com/events/caju6jn3onuvtkct9scbt0808u4?authkey=CJusmPqj5MvdyAE
Back Channel: Twitter hashtag #okfnedu
Chair: Marieke Guy
Participants: Add your name, Skype address and email address if you are participating
http://education.okfn.org/7th-open-education-working-group-call-open-data-as-open-educational-resources/
- Marieke Guy, Open Knowledge
- Leo Havemann: Birkbeck, University of London
- Javiera Atenas: University College London
- William Hammonds: Universities UK
- Virginia Power - UWE - information and knowledgement - tutor and phd - recommender systems - oers
- Chiar
- Tore Hoel, Oslo and Akershus University College of Applied Sciences, Oslo (Skype: odintorloke - Twitter: @tore)
- Tim Coughlan - OU @t1mc tim.coughlan@open.ac.uk
- Lorna Campbell - EDINA, University fo Edinburgh, lorna.m.campbell@icloud.com, @lornamcampbell,
- Phil Barker
- Chiara Ciociola:
- Tom Salmon: Cape Peninsula University of Technology - tomsalmon@yahoo.com - @fishytom - tom.salmon.work.skype
Agenda
- Intro to group & call - Marieke (5 mins) - run over last minutes
- Opportunity for attendees to introduce themselves and give a brief overview of the open education related project and activities they are involved with (time depends on number)
- Presentations:
Slides - http://education.okblogfarm.org/files/2015/06/ODasOER.pdf
- Leo Havemann: Birkbeck, University of London
- Javiera Atenas: University College London
- William Hammonds: Universities UK - UUK work on open data, the opportunity for developing a briefing making the case for open data as an OER as part of this work and to ask whether anyone has case studies that could be used.
- Questions & discussion
Part 1
Opportunity for attendees to introduce themselves and give a brief overview of the open education related project and activities they are involved with. You don’t have to speak if you don’t want to, there’s no pressure. But if you have something you’d like to share then this will be the time.
Part 2
Talks on: Open Data as Open Educational Resources
Leo Havemann: Birkbeck, University of London
Javiera Atenas: University College London
William Hammonds: Universities UK
Notes
Tim - got students to build apps with open data - car parking data, worked with Tate
Tore - LACE, learning analytics, data sharing paper - on LACE site - data is becoming a learning resource - how can we make architectures so we can share data in a good way but still expose as open data
HI does anyone know of any instutions using a repository for open data (eg like CKAN) in order to host their research data that is being set up alongside an existing open access repository (eg. Dspace, ) - would be very interested to know of any examples - The DCC (http://www.dcc.ac.uk/) were keeping a list of all the UK institutional data repository set ups - might be work checking with them
Lincoln were using CKAN
I like the concept of open silos! Often they don't smell too good, so we need to fix that!
http://blog.universitiesuk.ac.uk/2015/05/05/supporting-the-student-experience-with-open-data/
Tore Hoel - Link to the report I referred to when I introduced myself on Data Sharing: http://www.laceproject.eu/deliverables/d7-2-data-sharing-roadmap/
The blog i mentioned with a bit of background about our UUK open data project http://blog.universitiesuk.ac.uk/2015/05/05/supporting-the-student-experience-with-open-data/
6th Open Education Working Group Call: Open education meta community online session
Working Group website: http://education.okfn.org
Working Group mailing list: https://lists.okfn.org/mailman/listinfo/open-education
Date: Tuesday 27 January at 4pm GMT - more details to follow on the mailing list.
Where:
Google hangout - (to participate): https://plus.google.com/hangouts/_/hoaevent/AP36tYf3PQJEY_Y_vaq1xw2Gk3-lTqzE_iyWrEDYfxpfp1STSYnL_g?authuser=0&hl=en-GB
Google Hangout on Air - (to view): https://plus.google.com/u/0/events/clo930fr43n2v84maiio5eikq9g
If you have troubles, use https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xPF8zLUxsBE
Back Channel: Twitter hashtag #okfnedu
Chair: Marieke Guy
Participants: Add your name, Skype address and email address if you are participating
- David Kernohan, OER-discuss
- Bekka Kahn, P2PU (p2pu.org / bekka@p2pu.org / @p2pu
- School of Open (project on P2PU: http://schoolofopen.p2pu.org
- Stefan Dietze, W3C open Linked Education group
- Alastair Clark, Association for Learning Technology Open Ed Special Interest Group
- Beck Pitt, OER-Research Hub (http://oerresearchhub.org and http://oermap.org) @BeckPitt @OER_Hub
- Greg Wilson, Software Carpentry, http://software-carpentry.org / gvwilson@software-carpentry.org
- Cable Green, Creative Commons: @cgreen cable@creativecommons.org, Open Policy Network: https://openpolicynetwork.org/about & Institute for Open Leadership: https://openpolicynetwork.org/iol/
- Antonio Martínez-Arboleda, SCORE fellows,
- Lorna Campbell, https://lornamcampbell.wordpress.com/ CETIS, http://www.cetis.ac.uk/ and Open Scotland, http://openscot.net/ & LRMI: http://www.lrmi.net
- Victoria Vlad, Expert-Grup, Școala mea, http://scoalamea.md/, http://www.expert-grup.org/en/proiecte/item/916-gpsa-moldova/916-gpsa-moldova
- Christian Stracke, ICORE
- Marc Bogonovich, Openwords, Skype: Marc.Bogonovich, Marc.Bogonovich@Gmail.com
Apologies
- Fabian Tompsett, Wikimedia UK (fabian.tompsett@wikimedia.org.uk) - can no longer attend
- Robert Schuwer | Expert Open Education, GO-GN - can no longer attend
- Paul Bacsich, Beyond POERUP,
Viewers: Add your name, Skype address and email address if you are watching the call on Youtube
- Raniere Silva - After 30 minutes trying to connect and having troubles. =)
- Theo Kuechel skype: theokk @theokl theo.kuechel@gmail.com http://opencontenttoolkit.wikispaces.com/
- Tom Salmon
Agenda
Part 1
Opportunity for attendees to introduce themselves and give a brief overview of the open education related project and activities they are involved with. You don’t have to speak if you don’t want to, there’s no pressure. But if you have something you’d like to share then this will be the time.
We will work our through the participant list above.
‘meta community session’ or ‘open open session’ - an opportunity for different Open Education groups come along and introduce themselves.
5 minute or so pitch on the group, what it does, who it's audience is, when it meets (online or offline), it's unique selling points etc.
Part 2
- Review of previous minutes
Notes
OER Discuss
David Kernohan, OER-discuss - out of Jisc call #ukoer - lots of messages - everyone in oer in uk - not always getting messages - primarily focused around practitioners - experienced people - twitter community on tweet deck - Link to the OER-Discus
s mailing list archive: https://www.jiscmail.ac.uk/cgi-bin/webadmin?A1=ind1501&L=OER-DISCUSS#13 See the "What should I say" thread
Askedn on list why they found it valuable - still very active 3 years on
P2PU
Bekka Kahn, P2PU - distributed organisation - 4 staffers round world - tool called discourse - learning tool https://p2pu.org/en/ / www.community.p2pu.org
Creative Commons is a proud P2PU partner - with the School of Open: http://schoolofopen.p2pu.org
Open coalition - loose affiliation of groups - housed at Wikimedia UK - http://open-coalition.org/
Stefan Dietze, W3C open Linked Education group
Existed for some time - set up by Maddie
http://www.w3.org/community/opened/ - linked data and education
joining together initiatitves - linked unis and other inititiatives
LinkedUp Project
Alastair Clark, Association for Learning Technology Open Ed Special Interest Group
At-C is the main conference
ALT is https://www.alt.ac.uk/
Every 2 months there is a webinar - membership - some overlap with OER-discuss
Lots of newbies
OER conference in UK now very closely linked
OER sig is conference glue -
http://oer15.oerconf.org
No chairs for OER16
- Beck Pitt, OER-Research Hub (http://oerresearchhub.org and http://oermap.org) @BeckPitt @OER_Hub
http://oerresearchhub.org and http://oermap.org
ICORE is global as the name is saying:
ICORE = INternational Community for Open Research and Open Education
Greg - Software Carpentry
http://software-carpentry.org/pages/team.html is where our instructors are, http://software-carpentry.org/workshops/previous.html is where we've been, and http://software-carpentry.org/pages/dashboard.html is the state of our lessons
Lots of instructors - uses Github - online training course - educational psychlogy - why open is better
- Cable Green, Creative Commons: @cgreen cable@creativecommons.org, Open Policy Network: https://openpolicynetwork.org/about & Institute for Open Leadership: https://openpolicynetwork.org/iol/
The products of grants should be openly licensed - all publicly funded should be openly licensed
All data cc0
We move the money and change the environment in
Open Policy Network: https://openpolicynetwork.org/about & Institute for Open Leadership (IOL)
: https://openpolicynetwork.org/iol
Sub grants to OPN members in next few months - call for global experts
How to JOIN the Open Policy Network: https://openpolicynetwork.org/about/#join
14 fellows at the inagural IOL ... will be hosting the second IOL in late 2015 / early 2016 - likely in eastern Europe-ish
Lorna Campbell, https://lornamcampbell.wordpress.com/ CETIS, http://www.cetis.ac.uk/ and Open Scotland, http://openscot.net/ & LRMI: http://www.lrmi.net
Cetis is the Centre for Education Technology and Interoperability Standards (http://www.cetis.ac.uk/). We are a technology advisory service based in the UK, but providing education technology consultancy services internationally. Cetis works in the area of open standards, open education technology, and open education policy and practice. Cetis provided the technology strategy and support to the UKOER Programmes and produced an open book Into The Wild (http://publications.cetis.ac.uk/2012/601) synthesising the programmes' technical outputs. We have recently worked on the Leanring Resource Metadata Initiaitve (http://lrmi.net/) with Creative Commons and the Assoication of Education Publishers and are now taking this work forward with the Dublin Core Metadata Initiaitve.
Cetis is also one of the founding partners of the Open Scotland initiative. Open Scotland (http://openscot.net/) is a voluntary cross sector initiative that aims to raise awareness of open education, encourage the sharing of open educational resources, and explore the potential of open policy and practice to benefit all sectors of Scottish education. We have also produced the Scottish Open Education Declaration, and open community draft based on the UNESCO / COL Paris OER Declaration (http://declaration.openscot.net/)
cetis been around for 12 years
Work has become part of practice - technology support for UKoer
Open
Scottish open education declaration - focal point for discussions
Quick plug for "into the wild", a great CETIS publicatio
n on the geekier end of OER http://publications.cetis.ac.uk/2012/601
Victoria Vlad, Expert-Grup, Școala mea, http://scoalamea.md/, http://www.expert-grup.org/en/proiecte/item/916-gpsa-moldova/916-gpsa-moldova
Social accountability - open data on budgets in all schools in Moldova - trying to grow interest
- Christian Stracke, ICORE
ICORE = International - need to combine open research and open education - pushing people to pushing for openness - joining with UNESCO and OCD
nal Community for Open Research and Open Education, see: www.ICORE-online.org
Mention of open discovery space in showcasing how open education can work - biggest initiative on open education
LINQ conference
First initiative that I Mentioned: ODS = Open Discovery Space, see: www.opendiscoveryspace.eu
- Marc Bogonovich, Openwords, Skype: Marc.Bogonovich, Marc.Bogonovich@Gmail.com
Foreign language app for - all content open source
revenue models for open data
Denis - working on open computing course
Map Lesotho: https://maplesotho.wordpress.com/2015/01/20/tension-excitement-mad-chatter-and-a-major-milestone/
POERUP
For general information it may be useful to you know that we are just starting a study project for the European Parliament on “Adult Education and OER in the EU” (for which we seek input, though just 8 out of 28 EU countries will be studied in any detail) and just finishing the final report on SharedOER for the EU’s Joint Research Centre IPTS unit. There is a bit more on the wiki page http://poerup.referata.com/wiki/Beyond_POERUP
POERUP and Beyond will be attending OER15 (at least 4 papers on POERUP and related topics) and hope to send someone to Open Education Global in Banff in April where we just heard we have two papers accepted.
Community Session: Presenting the Open Education Handbook
Date: Thursday Dec 11, 2014 - 10.00-11.00AM UTC
Where:
Google hangout - (to participate): https://plus.google.com/events/c5r4v67tst9k8be9as3p08i405k
Google Hangout on Air - (to view):
Facilitated and presented by: Christian Villum (Open Knowledge), Marieke Guy (Open Knowledge and Open Education Working Group co-ordinator), Rob Farrow (Open University)
Attendees: Martin Poulter, WikimediaUK
Jo Paulger - FLOSS manuals
Agenda
- Brief introduction to the Open Education Working Group & LinkedUp Project - MG
- History of handbook so far (background, booksprints, friday chats, online collaboration, translation to Portuguese, target audience is for the book and who it benefits) - MG
- Current status of handbook - contents, layout, formats, what's missing - RF
- Next steps? - where could it go (outline of options), how can it be updated, translation, how can it be reused, other projects that can benefit from it? Does anything else like this exist in this space?
Do you have any questions you would like to be asked?
Hi I'd like to find out more about other resources available on this topic
Mick Chesterman:
I would suggest creating a splash page for the manual like this one. Which offers a quick way to download the book in epub, pdf - and invites further contributions.
http://collaborative-futures.org/
(Unfortunately, the link there for HTML points to booki.cc which is no longer maintained. I'll try to find them to ask them to update that link to here - http://flossmanuals.net/collaborative-futures/ )
In terms of how the HTML pages are presented, a little bit of scripting could create a themed version of the published manual. What I mean by this is that some branding of the OKF or the writing project could be put into the header and footer of each chapter page.
This is how the civicrm community like to do things at http://book.civicrm.org/ - They write on a booktype platform at flossmanuals.net - but publish a themed HTML version with their own URL. They are then able to keep older versions as an archive here. http://book.civicrm.org/user/version/index.php
Wikibooks:
Wikibook edition of the handbook in progress here: https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Open_education_handbook_2014
Wikibooks is
* a sister project to Wikipedia. User accounts on WP work on Wikibooks. Same editing interface.
* quieter than Wikipedia: no problem with trolls or hoaxers
* meant for manuals, how-tos, recipes and textbooks - less constrained than an encyclopedia
* able to support features such as PDF export and within-book search
* like all Wikimedia projects, truly free: reusable by anyone for any purpose under CC-BY-SA
* massively multilingual. For example, Portugese version here: https://pt.wikibooks.org/
* connected to Wikimedia Commons: any of WC's 24 million open-content media files can be embedded in Wikibooks
Featured books section of Wikibooks already includes books on open educational practice, blended learning, Library ICT etc. : https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Wikibooks:Featured_books
Process of importing book into Wikibooks has resulted in a list of minor errors such as typos. This will be available as a Google Doc to anyone who is hosting a version of the handbook.
Subsequent changes to the Wikibook can be monitored through the Watchlist feature of the wiki, or machine-readably via the API.
Wikibooks wants:
* Other books/manuals licensed compatibly (CC-BY-SA or CC-BY) that can be imported.
* Editors/proofreaders : just create an account, read the books and correct any errors you find.
* Illustrators: find an existing image on Wikimedia Commons to illustrate a Wikibook page, or upload freely-licensed images to Commons.
* Other communities who want to collaboratively build a book reflecting current knowledge on any topic (could be a group of students on an assignment).
NB: Wikibooks content is supposed to be descriptive "how-to", not a catalogue of web sites. Some OE Handbook sections are mainly links lists, but I advise against that style.
5th Open Education Working Group Call
Working Group website: http://education.okfn.org
Working Group mailing list: https://lists.okfn.org/mailman/listinfo/open-education
Date: Monday 29th September 3pm - 4pm BST / 4pm - 5pm CEST
Where:
Google hangout - (to participate): https://plus.google.com/hangouts/_/hoaevent/AP36tYctJojW_Cgz1g-95ffNGbyruNgOiEyT6u8rpBSN_R4UVnPk5A?authuser=0&hl=en-GB
Google Hangout on Air - (to view): https://plus.google.com/u/0/ehttps://pad.okfn.org/p/Open_Education_Working_Group_Callvents/c8ihldgo3e4nn2usah9odrchqm0
Back Channel: Twitter hashtag #okfnedu
Chair: Marieke Guy
Participants: Add your name, Skype address and email address if you are participating
- Marieke Guy, Open Knowledge Foundation (BST - London time)
- Marco Fioretti http://mfioretti.com (GMT+2 Rome time)
- Bernard Nkuyubwatsi, Nkuyubwatsi1 (BST-London Time)
- Javiera Atenas
- Marco Fioretti
- Paul Richardson, Jisc regional support centre, Wales
- Laura Hilliger, Mozilla (CET)
- Tore Hoel, HiOA, Norway
- Irina Radchenko
Agenda
Part 1
Opportunity for attendees to introduce themselves and give a brief overview of the open education related project and activities they are involved with. You don’t have to speak if you don’t want to, there’s no pressure. But if you have something you’d like to share then this will be the time.
Part 2
Invited talks
- Marco Fioretti, freelance writer, popularizer, activist and teacher, will talk about using open data in schools. See his recent blog post for more details.
- Marco Fioretti: I will explain how I came to make this proposal and why
- Advisory Board member Rayna Stamboliyska, also board member of Open Knowledge France and founder of its Open/Citizen Science workgroup, is in the process of setting up the very first ‘data expedition for kids’. Rayna will tell us how plans are coming along and hopefully spark a discussion on innovative approaches to learning and the implications for open education.
- Javiera Atenas - translation of Creative Commons resources
- Bernard on Lyon Declaration and its implication on the post 2015 education
- Speakers or topics for next time?
- Future events? Future project? Future activities?
- AOB
Notes
- Javiera - Just finished her Phd - will be released fairly soon - CC-BY - 6 papers - also open access!
- Laura - Web maker - helping peopel dve into mechanics, curriculum and citizenship of making stuff for the web
- http://webmaker.org and http://training.webmakerprototypes.org (contextual information on building for Webmaker, cMOOCs and edu models can be found on my blog: http://zythepsary.com )
- At the end of October we're hosting the annual Mozilla Festival (in London), and you should all join us! http://mozillafestival.org
- Paul involved with a Working group appointed by Welsh government - looking at OER - challenging to keep up with everything
- Discussion over Marieke moving on to other projects and keen to spread the co-ordination of the group out a little - Javiera will be able to spend more time supporting in the new year
- Discussion over the concept of building a Community' other related communities include: Open education graduate community, UNESCo group, OER discuss, GO-GN (Global Open Educational Resources Gradute Network), ALT's OER SIG committee
- In Open communities there is a lot of overlap - where are the bridges?
- There thumbs up for people who bounce between communities!
- Suggestion that we maybe have a meta community day - invite other OER communities - 'OpenOpen' Day +1! meta - open
Marco gave talk on possibilites of open data use in schools for teaching (http://www.slideshare.net/mfioretti/open-data-in-and-from-schools) - Collecting and using open data as part of normal school work - using open data in school for raw materials eg. figures from open corporates. Marco explained that currently schools teach with data but it is old data or made up data out of text books, possibly on a scanned PDF. It is not reuseable data, it rarely raises the interests of children - and is doing nothing to improve interest of young people in politics or future government. This means that many young peope don't care about activism. Marco argued that this was different from expecting teachers to learn programming, teaching stats is something they are already doing.
Marco has explored these ideas in a workshop at GD Camp in Warsaw. He has now started to collect practical examples on the topic - how teachers can begin to use open data through example lesson plans etc. This is something teachers have to do anyway!
Javiera - is really important, and also for universities to start releasing data so academics can reuse that as real data for students understanding complex problems
also.... what about school of data using open data as examples, for example on understanding budgeting. Other aras working in this space: School of Open, Webmaker Training
The discussion in the chat considered that this relates to having learners work on real world problems by contributing - citizen science activities. Mozilla carry out interest based learning, so the learners define what is important to them and then learn web literacy competencies and skills from that lens. References included Moneythan ? Spaghetti Forks? Issues identified were teachres being too busy and feeling incompetent in this area. Discussion on possible project proposal ideas related to supoorting teachers.
Javiera introduced the issue of Creative Commons resources being mainly only available in English. Would like to see co-ordinated translation of resources.
She would love to be able to just switch flags and have the page available in other languages
Question of if the translations are already there -
https://www.transifex.com/projects/p/CC/
http://creativecommons.org/choose/
School of Open, Webmaker Training
Duolingo has learners translate the web while learning a new language. So people are effectively contributing to open translation efforts.
Bernard talked about Lyon Declaration and its implication on the post 2015 education (http://www.lyondeclaration.org).
The Lyon Declaration is an advocacy document that will be used to positively influence the content of the United Nations post-2015 development agenda. It was drafted by IFLA and a number of strategic partners in the library and development communities between January and May 2014. Government of Rwanda is considering an open education policy
Bernard are you in contact with OLE Rwanda? www.olerwanda.org
4th Open Education Working Group Call
Working Group website: http://education.okfn.org
Working Group mailing list: https://lists.okfn.org/mailman/listinfo/open-education
Date: Tuesday 8th July 3:00pm - 4:00pm BST BST (London time!) on (Strict limit of one hour)
Where:
Google hangout - (to participate) - https://plus.google.com/hangouts/_/hoaevent/AP36tYcnkDXq7Wyy0umZpkH83UG1xRswtY6uNwtvx10SuEP3z41zxQ?authuser=0&hl=en-GB
Google Hangout on Air - (to view) - https://plus.google.com/events/crj66bc4pi24pcpnr1d9jeartso
Back Channel: Twitter hashtag #okfnedu
Chair: Marieke Guy
Participants: Add your name, Skype address and email address if you are participating
- Marieke Guy, Open Knowledge Foundation (BST - London time)
- Mick Chesterman
- Martin Ebner (mebner@gmx.at)
- Denis Parfenov, denis.parfenov@openknowledge.ie
- Tore Hoel. tore.hoel@hioa.no - Skype:odintorloke
- Li Yan - Cetis
- Sebastian Horndasch - Wikimedia Deutschland
- Tom Salmon
Agenda
Part 1
Opportunity for attendees to introduce themselves and give a brief overview of the open education related project and activities they are involved with. You don’t have to speak if you don’t want to, there’s no pressure. But if you have something you’d like to share then this will be the time.
Part 2
Meeting Notes & Action Items
Standardisation discussion - where should more informal discussion take place re: standards and IPR?
Not very easy to decide on appropriate angle - how do we engage the stakeholders who have influence in this field - lot of thinking
Question to ponder on: What would be the aspect of standards that are closest to the heart of OER / Open Education enthusiasts - and that would bring the discussion on open standards forward? Data sharing of LA data? Metadata description of OERs? IPR descriptions (well, that one is done via CC?)....
Talks
Aspects to be discussed from Martin's presentation
a. LA applications (as he showed example of) as OER - how to make them available for students and their parents (for school apps)
b. What are the data to be shared from these apps?
- Mick Chesterman from Floss manuals will talk about Duct Tape University – an OER discovery and publishing tool for learning communities
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3rd Open Education Working Group Call
Working Group website: http://education.okfn.org
Working Group mailing list: https://lists.okfn.org/mailman/listinfo/open-education
Date: Monday 12th May 4:30pm - 5:30pm BST (London time!) on (Strict limit of one hour)
Where:
Google hangout - https://plus.google.com/hangouts/_/hoaevent/AP36tYd8a5mmw56PkPGODMQzEuE48BDDW0TuNl6OXXlAj6qH46KvoA?authuser=0&hl=en-GB (to participate)
Google Hangout on Air - https://plus.google.com/events/cok9uaqpdptrf0jcrifp4q1hai8 (to view)
Back Channel: Twitter hashtag #okfnedu
Chair: Marieke Guy
Participants: Add your name, Skype address and email address if you are participating
- Marieke Guy, Open Knowledge Foundation (BST - London time)
- Tore Hoel, Oslo and Akershus University College of Applied Sciences / NordicOER project Skype: odintorloke CEST
- Cable Green, Creative Commons: skype: cable.green PDT
- Lorna M Campbell, Cetis, Skype: lorna120768 (BST - London time)
- Bernard Nkuyubwatsi, University of Leicester, Skype: nkuyubwatsi1 (BST - London time)
- Mariah N Villarreal, OpenEd Jam, mariah@openedjam.org - CDT
- Adam Cooper, Cetis (BST - London time)
Apologies from Rayna Stamboliyska
Notes
Agenda
Part 1
Opportunity for attendees to introduce themselves and give a brief overview of the open education related project and activities they are involved with. You don’t have to speak if you don’t want to, there’s no pressure. But if you have something you’d like to share then this will be the time.
Hello from the Open Education Advisory Board members!!
Part 2
Meeting Notes & Action Items
Pre-standardisation discussion
- Questions on IPR related to specifications
- Competition within domain - industry consortia & other areas to own conversation
- In Europe no activities that could be referred to as pre-standardisation
- Lorna - Potentially role for a body to facilitate discussions about open standards
- Different initiatives going on else where in the world
- Lot of flux in the standards world at the moment
- Risk of doing nothing -
- Good properties of a good pre-standardisation body - messy ground - flux
- Not got much of a critical mass of people who are interested
- Adam's blog: http://blogs.cetis.ac.uk/adam/
- need to engage commerical sector
- Role of governments and European commission
- dam's blog: http://blogs.cetis.ac.uk/adam/
- Adam's blog on "Interoperability Incubation and Pre-standardisation Activity – A View on Desirable Qualities" http://blogs.cetis.ac.uk/adam/2014/02/21/interoperability-incubation-and-pre-standardisation-activity-a-view-on-desirable-qualities/
- ETAG
- Just place for community to talk or long term strategy
- Multiple venues for this space
- People don't want to get involved
- "Conversations in a context" - things feed in to discussions elsewhere
- Standards are hard
- Difficult thing to do - loud voices - puts people off
- CC & LRMI & Schema.org & publishers
- metadata means OER can be easier, filtered - imagine a world where it is easier to remix
- Transaction level data - open learning analytics
- Learning is way behind
- Standardisation focused on projects - what happens between the projects - keeping the community going
- Need for some infrastructure & facilitatiion - what are you doing? Role for OK? Need to communicatie to the rest of the community
- People need to report back
- http://www.lrmi.net
- UKOER - periodic stuff on Twitter
- Potentially could be a funded project in this area
- Discussions on what we want to do in the same ways and what we want to do in different ways
- Bernard - standards, some local realities might be ignore. Which complicate practices in some local settings.
- @Adam: I like that flexibility. I think it will be a strong enabler to build on.
- What is a course - conceptual level of work
- Is it worth having an online event - open data, open education and open standards - mutual relationships between
- LACE project - http://www.laceproject.eu
- Possibly have an event
- Launch some discussions on pre-standardisation
- Bernard - question on where is the added value to people of standardisation?
- Alienating to people
- Open standards - difficult process to get there - lack a good process where the significant points for action are
- http://slidewiki.org
- collaborative authoring tool
- Slidewiki - counterparts -
- Area of interest - Workshop iKnow - Learning Analytics data sharing - LACE
- Roadmap with data sharing - open data - research data
- 'Learning Analytics' - where does standards fit
- personal data - Marieke and Adam to have a discussion offline about possible people
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2nd Open Education Working Group Call
Working Group website: http://education.okfn.org
Working Group mailing list: https://lists.okfn.org/mailman/listinfo/open-education
Date: Thursday, 13th March 1:30pm-2:30pm, GMT on (Strict limit of one hour)
Where:
Google hangout https://plus.google.com/hangouts/_/hoaevent/AP36tYfj0DAHrsF-E7rq8RDewBISVXEmX17VRwbUNcZIiXiTnhzKow?authuser=0&hl=en-GB (to participate)
Google Hangout on Air https://plus.google.com/events/co47qbprf6k3so0iao01cpi1f6g (to view)
Back Channel: Twitter hashtag #okfnedu
Chair: Marieke Guy
Participants: Add your name, Skype address and email address if you are participating
- Marieke Guy, Open Knowledge Foundation
- Bernard Nkuyubwatsi, Skype ID: nkuyubwatsi1, bn30@le.ac.uk
- André Jaenisch, German student in Stuttgart, email: andre.jaenisch@openmailbox.org, @andrejaenisch
- Joe Wilson @joecar - not able to get into hangout and only countdown on live stream - wanted to update folks on this http://openscot.net/declaration/ sorry need to go to my next meeting got times wrong
- Raniere Silva, Brazilian student, Open Knowledge Foundation - Brazil Chapter
- Tore Hoel, Oslo and Akershus University College of Applied Sciences , Norway - http://nordicoer.org (only fo 30 minutes) Skype:odintorloke
- Paul Stacey, Creative Commons, Skype paulstacey1, pstacey@creativecommons.org
- Darya Tarasowa, SkypeID: vassilisha, darya.tarasowa@gmail.com
- Jan M. Pawlowski, skype jan_m_pawlowski, jan.pawlowski@hs-ruhrwest.de
- Alexander Maasch, Open KnowledgeWorker (www.openknowledgeworker.org ), maasch@openknowledgeworker.org, Skype: amaasch
- Henri Pirkkalainen, project researcher, University of Jyväskylä, henri.j.pirkkalainen@jyu.fi, Skype: henrip83
- Louis M Coiffait - Head of Research, Office of the Chief Education Advisor, Pearson, Thinktank louiscrusoe@gmail.com https://twitter.com/LouisMMCoiffait
Notes
I (Suchith Anand) would like to send apologies for not being able to attend today's meetings . I would like to update on plans to organise "Building up Open Access and Open Education for Open Science" on Sep 2nd 2014 in parellel to OSGIS 2014 at the University of Nottingham. This is inspired from the Building up Open Science for Future challenges meeting i attended in Warsaw earlier this week where i presented on Open Geospatial Science developments (which integrated the synergies between the various Open communities- Open Data, Open Standards and Open Source). We would like to build upon these experiences to bring together synergies in Open Access and Open Education for further building up Open Science. I will update on this in the next meeting and also through our maillists. I am looking forward for strong participation from the Open education community.
Agenda
Part 1
Opportunity for attendees to introduce themselves and give a brief overview of the open education related project and activities they are involved with. You don’t have to speak if you don’t want to, there’s no pressure. But if you have something you’d like to share then this will be the time.
Part 2
- Review of previous minutes
- Working Group structure: advisory board - update, membership list, invited speaker at calls?
- Brainstorming: current high-level open education goals, then existing (and active) initiatives, then discuss the gaps to clarify working group purpose
- Open education Week - What are you up to?
- Not a lot of interest - public not knowledgable about it - too much
- OKFest - what are you up to?
- Tools - Andre Jaenisch
Meeting Notes & Action Items
Introductions to all attendees
Advisory Board members
- Rayna Stamboliyska - Based in Paris, France - OKF France Board Member, founder of its Open/Citizen Science workgroup, former project coordinator for a project bringing scientific research to primary schools. Interested in learning by doing and alternative schooling with focus on the Global South and MENA.
- Bernard Nkuyubwatsi- Member of Task Force for University of Rwanda College of Open and Distance !earning and eTutor
- Karien Bezuidenhout - Shuttleworth foundation
- Lorna M. Campbell Cetis specialises in technology innovation and interoperability standards in learning, education and training.
- Louis M Coiffait - Head of Research, Office of the Chief Education Advisor, Pearson Thinktank
- Cable Green Director of Global Learning at Creative Commons
Plans to create a mailing list for members. Members of the Open Education Working Group Working Group are publicly listed individuals who volunteer time to evangelise about open data, content and/or knowledge in the Open Education field. Members coordinate the activities of the Working Group with the support of the Open Knowledge Foundation community team.
Open education Week - What are you up to? ELOGeo is activily involved for this http://www.openeducationweek.org/the-elogeo-repository/
Discussion around #openeducationwk - tto many activities? Webinars not well attended, need to bring others beyond open community
Key activity areas:
- LRMI (http://www.lrmi.net) - pre standardisation area - beyond metadata - we could maybe brainstorm current standards initiatives
- Multilingual activity, translation of less used languages
- Lobbying for change of mindset
- Activity around language we use to describe open education (non-specialists) - issues and concepts - common language
- Policy level collaboration (unesco) - large organisations working together - maybe something for advisory board - holistic perspective
Tools based on discussion: https://twitter.com/AndreJaenisch/status/435790145074106371
Agenda for next time: Would like us to focus on a couple of activity area/ issues - individuals can offer input statements (couple of minutes) on some of the topics.
- Jan has offered to something on internationalisation
- Important to schedule times so US can participate - probably 5pm GMT
- Marieke will try and come up with some Working Group Call dates so we can plan into future
- US Influence - they are engaging with open - mention of Audrey Waters & Aneesh Chopra (former US CIO) or somebody from current Dept Ed (Arne Duncan) - would be good to get these people involved.
Links
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1st Open Education Working Group Call
Working Group website: http://education.okfn.org
Working Group mailing list: https://lists.okfn.org/mailman/listinfo/open-education
Date: Friday 24th January, 3pm-4pm GMT on (Strict limit of one hour)
Where: Google Hangout https://plus.google.com/hangouts/_/hoaevent/AP36tYcJImmHuI1GND8IH_czWq4O82Y_oi7V3wxqzAn6ACMBQIdF7g?authuser=0&hl=en-GB Skype as backup Google hangout on air https://plus.google.com/events/c8tdq7i6bcc45tf5t4lanvqjk8c
Back Channel: Twitter hashtag #okfnedu
Chair: Marieke Guy
Participants: Add your name, Skype address and email address if you are participating
- Marieke Guy, Open Knowledge Foundation & LinkedUp Project, email: marieke.guy@okfn.org, Skype: mariekeguy
- Maraim Masoud, email: maraim.elbadri@gmail.com, elbadri11
- Cable Green, Creative Commons, e-mail: cable@creativecommons.org; Skype: cable.green; Twitter: @cgreen
- Chinasa Ikelu, email: icinasa@gmail.com, Skype: ici.nas
- Alek Tarkowski, Creative Commons Poland, alek@creativecommons.pl, Skype: alektarkowski
- Darya Tarasowa, University of Bonn, darya.tarasowa@gmail.com, skype:vassilisha
- Suchith Anand , University of Nottingham , suchith.anand@nottingham.ac.uk ; skype : sanand1976
- Tore Hoel, Nordic OER project, Oslo and Akershus University College of Applied Sciences, tore.hoel@hioa.no; skype:odintorloke [on air, yes!]
- Andre Jaenisch, German student, email: andre.jaenisch@openmailbox.org (hangout on air only, without sound due to technical reasons)
- Raniere Silva, Brazilian undergraduate students, email: raniere@ime.unicamp.br
- Denis Parfenov, OKF Ireland; [email: denis.parfenov@okfirl.org; skype: dp0901]
- Mariah Noelle Villarreal, OpenEdJAM, Skype: mariahvillarreal, Email: villarrealmn@gmail.com
Notes
Agenda:
Part 1
Opportunity for attendees to introduce themselves and give a brief overview of the open education related project and activities they are involved with. You don’t have to speak if you don’t want to, there’s no pressure. But if you have something you’d like to share then this will be the time.
Part 2
- Brief introduction to the Open Education Working Group - history, what we are, what we are trying to do
- Working Group structure: advisory board, members? Take a look at the Charter http://education.okfn.org/charter/ - any comments?
- Working Group activities: next steps for the handbook, projects we could get involved with, what do you want to do in 2014?
- Working Group Calls: Time of calls e.g. The monthly calls of the Working Group on Open Education are at every 1st Thursday / month at 17:30 GMT / 18:30 CEST / 12:30 EST - can reschedule if necessary - or should they be adhoc?? Chairing.
- Ideas for responsibilty borrowed from the Open Science Working Group:
- Organising working group meetings
- Planning open education events at OKFest 2014
- Documenting events and updates from the working group
- Coordinating specific projects or documents
- Blog Editing
- Tech/Dev Liaison
- Event Organisation
- Designing publicity materials and logos etc.
- Mailing list
- Blog Editors
- Website and Social Media
- Local Groups
- WG and Advisory Board Meetings
- General Coordination
Suggestions for alternates to Google Hangouts from Andre Jaenisch
For this one, it may be too late. But maybe, alternatives like Palava.TV
(https://palava.tv/info/how) in combination with Together.JS
(https://togetherjs.com/) can be used. I'll have to check it out, to
make a better/more concrete suggestion. Hence I'll look after finding
time to watch the records afterwards
Meeting Notes & Action Items
Intersting links in session:
Advisory board
http://education.okfn.org/charter/
http://science.okfn.org/about-us/advisory-board/
Joonas Mäkinen, Finland (https://twitter.com/JoonasD6)
http://science.okfn.org/about-us/advisory-board/
Need details of what they are expected to do - once every 6 months
Email for nominations for advisory board - keeping it open
Ideas from community
Kristina Alexanderson, Sweden (https://twitter.com/kalexanderson) open education - OKFest kristina.alexanderson@gmail.com
Louis Coiffait, Pearson, UK https://twitter.com/LouisMMCoiffait
Activities
maybe some collaboration and support of http://www.lrmi.net/ initiatives? - CC is currently funding 10 OER repositories/registries to implement LRMI, including Jorum. http://wiki.creativecommons.org/LRMI/Implementation
Open Education Handbook - http://education.okfn.org/handbook/
We need concrete challenges - don't take no for an answer
Reuse of educational resources - OER circle
OUUK evidence hub: http://ci.olnet.org/
http://oerresearchhub.org
How these resources are changing education?
How OER works alongside MOOC
Licensing with Creative Commons
How to use OER in different languages and by small languages
All issues related to OER and Small languages and Cultures
Multilingualism
Marieke to look into organising a workshop at OKFest 2014, 15–18 July, in Berlin, Germany
Call/organisation
Vary the time for the meeting - 2 variations
once a month
ICORE - similar aims - reach out to them
It would be useful to brainstorm current high-level open education goals, then existing (and active) initiatives, then discuss the gaps. It's difficult to understand the goals/aims of this working group.